I SAW THE TV GLOW

US, 2024, 100 minutes, Colour.

Justice Smith, Brigette Lundy-Paine, Ian Foreman, Helena Howard, Lindsey Jordan, Danielle Deadwyler, Fred Durst.

Directed by Jane Schoenbrun.

Certainly a provocative title. And, alluring for those who love television and are caught up in its worlds. It has been billed as a horror film but that sets up expectations which may not be fulfilled and distracts an audience from trying to discern what kind of film it actually is.

The first comment is that it has divided opinions, right down the middle, many declaring it is one of the most boring films they have ever seen, finding it incomprehensible, many, on the other hand, praising its originality, its insight into youth and absorption into fantasy with consequences on real life.

Another approach would be that young audiences who are on its wavelength, identify with the characters, not only their response to the glow of television and television series, but in their personal issues, especially of family and parental experiences, loneliness and isolation, identity, gender and sexual identity. Older audiences may find themselves in a state of observing with interest, rather than identifying with the characters and the action.

The film was the work of writer-director, Jane Schoenbrun, who has given the number of interviews about their perspective on the film and its creation, its relationship to the director’s own life, awareness and decisions about gender identity and transitions.

The story opens in 1996, two high schoolers, Maddy (Brigitte Lundy-Paine), morose but strong minded, who lives with an abusive father, Owen (Justice Smith who tells the story and is the focal character) who lives with his parents, a stern father, she two years older than he. What brings them together is an interest in a television series, The Pink Opaque (with reference to the series, Buffy, the Vampire Slayer). Two loners meet and discuss their experiences and lives, Maddy attracted to girls, Owen unsure, attracted to the television series. The possibility arises that they could run away from home, Maddy doing so, Owen staying.

There are two time lapses during the action which jolt the audience, Maddy’s return after eight years, absorbed in the series, partly living the fantasy, the audience seeing some of the fantasy characters. Owen, on the other hand, has a humdrum life, works in the theatre which now closes down and he has to move to a fun fair.

Then a gap of 20 years, Owen, the same but visibly older, adapting his life, trapped in the memories, and a literal scream of desperation.

Which means then that the director offers a story and treatment and then it is over to us make of it what we will, what we can.

1. The title, television and its impact, American audiences, younger audiences, teenage audiences, the 1990s setting, Buffy the Vampire Slayer and its influence? The repercussions as protagonists grew older? The Pink Opaque?
2. The time settings, the mid-1990s, advancing two years, the gap of eight years, then 20 years and the sudden jolt for audience attention? The later years?
3. The perspective of the writer-director, her comments about her own life experience, gender and transgender, growing awareness, consequences?
4. The story of Owen, quiet, character, physical and psychological conditions? His age, at school, observing Maddy, her reading the book about The Pink Opaque, the discussions, friendship, his wanting to see the episodes, his curfew at home, going to her house, the excuse of the sleepovers, later visiting the mother of his former friend for her support? The effect of watching the episodes, their coming to life, the various characters, the girls, the villains each week, Mr Melancholy and appearances, Owen absorbed?
5. Maddy’s story, family, abusive stepfather, wanting to leave, her age, befriending Owen, her disappearance? The sexual orientation, conscious, choices, to leave family in town?
6. Maddy giving Owen the VHS cassettes, his watching them, absorbed, the characters, the stories, the mythology? Effect on him?
7. Owen, relationship with his mother, African-American family, severe father, dismissing The Pink Opaque as for girls, remaining in the town, getting the jobs, quiet, his appearance, hair, slender, looking at himself in the mirror, the issue of relationships, girls, identity, male/female?
8. Maddy’s return after eight years, her story about her jobs, her life, and living within the episodes of the show, the characters, their behaviour? Revealing this to Owen? His reactions, watching the show, smashing his head in the television set, his father saving him?
9. Owen, staying at home, reticent, working in the movie theatre? The closure of the theatre, going to work in the Fun Park?
10. The passing of time, Owen getting older, grey hair, stooped, nondescriptive existence? 2026, the outburst at the fair, the desperate screaming, no response from people, his returning home, cutting his chest, the television set glowing within? His return and apology? Whatever his future?
11. The effect on the audience in the style of storytelling, events, long conversations, realism, fantasy, intermingling of both, personal identity, gender and sexual identity, isolation?