IN A VALLEY OF VIOLENCE

US, 2016, 97 minutes, Colour.

Ethan Hawke, John Travolta, Taissa Farmiga, James Ransone, Karen Gillan, Toby Huss, Burn Gorman.

Directed by Ti West.

Writer-director, Ti West, began his career with ventures into horror films, gaining great deal of attention with the Innkeepers in 2011. What he continued his career with films, his main work was in television until the 2020s when he made a series of films, well received, starring Mia Goth, sometimes a blend of sex and horror, X, Pearl, Maxxxine. However, this is a Western revenge.

Ethan Hawke plays the central character, Paul, ex-army, having left his wife and daughter, wandering, initially encountering a bogus preacher, Burn Gorman, taking his horse, riding into an abandoned mining town.

While minding his own business in the saloon, he is confronted by an exceedingly brash self-centred Healy, James Ransone, who challenges him to a fight. Paul simply knocks him out. However, Gilly is the son of the local Marshall, an interesting role for 60 year old John Travolta. There are two young women running the local hotel,, Karen Gillan, and the young Maryann, Taissa Farmiga, who is attracted to the stranger.

While the Marshall arranges a kind of peace, Paul rides out of town with his dog (whom everybody admires and asks whether he can do tricks, Paul relying that he bites, though we do see a few tricks, especially his wrapping himself in a blanket!), Gilly and his associates kill the dog, threatening Paul, throwing him from a cliff. He survives.

Which means then that he will return, wreak vengeance on each of the members of the group – which he does. And there will be a confrontation with the Marshall.

Audience emotion is on Paul’s side while they are of the conscience issues of the wreaking vengeance (and his strong motivation of revenge because of the killing of the dog).

Quite an effective vengeance Western achieving what it set out to do.

1. The title, expectations? The Western context?
2. The location photography, town, the streets, bar, Marshall’s office, jail, hotel rooms, the countryside, the mountains? The musical score?
3. Paul and his story, background of enlistment, his war experience, the effect on him, leaving his wife and daughter, his companionship with his dog, talking to the dog? The encounter with the priest, hostile, violent, taking his horse? Arriving in the town, searching for Dollar Bill, in the saloon?
4. Gilly, boasting, the salesman and his field, ousted, Gilly confronting Paul, silent, the challenge to the fight, the five dollar bet, the barman and his caution? Crowd gathering, Paul punching Gilly, his collapse?
5. The Marshall, meeting Paul, the discussions, Gilly his son, Deputy, a father’s care? Willing Paul off? And his encounter with Mary Anne, the bath, flirting, Mary Anne and her relationship with Ellen, Gilly’s fiance, urging him on?
6. Paul leaving, camping, with the dog, the ambush by Gilly and his men, the shooting of the dog, threatening Paul, on the is one, pushing him over? His recovery, returning to the town, spirit of vengeance?
7. Paul and his return, the welcomed by Mary Anne? Roy, his manner, the bath, with Mary Anne, Paul coming in, the confrontation, killing him, the blood? Ellen and her response?
8. The Marshall, confronting Gilly, beating him? Yet protecting him? The plan, Harris going onto the roof, Paul confronting him, the final conversation, Paul merciless, shooting him? Tubby, his fear, urged by the Marshall, his self-assertion, against Tubby, his name Lawrence, standing in the window, shot?
9. Gilly, searching for Paul? Paul and the confrontation with the Marshall, out in the street, the Marshall laying down his arms, Gilly confronting, the challenge, the shooting, the death of the Marshall?
10. The barn, Gilly searching, the news, the fight? Going to the hotel? The women, Gilly and his protecting them, and her pregnancy, Gilly and his surly response?
11. Paul, telling Mary Anne his story, her supporting him? The future?