THE ORDER

US, 2024, 116 minutes, Colour.

Jude Law, Nicholas Hoult, Tyler Sheridan, Jurnee Smollett, Walter Slezak, Odessa Young Alison Oliver.

Directed by Justin Kurzel.

The events in this investigative thriller took place in the 1980s. But, a film about extreme right-wing groups in the United States in the 2020s will immediately alert audiences to the attack on the American capital, January 6th, 2021. And, in fact, at the end of the film, the link is made.

The name, The Order is taken from the 1977 novel by William L.Pierce, the Turner Diaries, seemingly intended for younger readers but something of a manual for an uprising against the state, and how it is achieved in stages. This book features in the film highlighting its influence. Already, in 1988, there was a film about these events, Betrayed, directed by Costa Gavras and featuring Tom Berenger and Debra Winger. Early in 1989, the book on which this film is based was published. Its title, The Silent Brotherhood: Inside an American Racist Conspiracy, by Kevin Flynn and Gary Gerhardt. Kevin Flynn is noted in the credit as a consultant for the film.

The film has been directed by Justin Kurzel, well noted for his crime dramas and his skill in portraying mentally and emotionally disturbed men – especially in Australia, The Snow Twown, The True Story of the Kelly Gang, Nitram (and not forgetting his Macbeth).

The framework of this story is the investigation by FBI agent, Terry Husk, a fine role for Jude Law, one of his best (his role before this one as the ageing Henry VIII in The Firebrand). He works in collaboration with an earnest young deputy, Jamie Bowen, played by Tye  Sheridan, and a local agent played by Jurnee Smollett. The setting is Washington State – so much of the scenery, the mountains, filmed beautifully as background.

At the centre of the brotherhood is a young enthusiast, all-American, Bob Matthews. This is a very interesting and different performance by Nicholas Hoult who resembles closely the photos of Matthews himself, at times baby faced, an innocent despite the prejudices and violence he is spouting (scenes of his intensity in close-up looking like Nicholas Hoult more than 20 years earlier as a boy in About the Boy). The actual Bob Matthews, we find there is a strong resemblance between him and Nicholas Hoult.

Terry Husk has his own personal problems, his long career, sometimes an intense recklessness in pursuing the criminals. Matthews has the support of his wife, of his pregnant girlfriend, of a lot of the Proud Boy types of the 1980s, moving to bank robberies, explosions to distract from the robberies, a Bricks job on the highway, building up his coffers to start a militia. The screenplay also emphasises the biblical underlining of this Brotherhood, the transfer of promised land to the Jews (to be taken away from them), to the white Americans who see themselves as God’s chosen people, ready to rise up against any immoral society and a two-permitting government.

The pace is strong. The characterisation powerful. The issue is more than challenging. And, while it is a reminder of movements in the past, The Unibomber, bombings in Oklahoma, Waco… It is a sober alert to movements, beliefs, conspiracy theories in Trump’s America.

1. The title, the reference to the book, The Turner Diaries, the manual for insurrections and the group called The Order?
2. The film based on fact, the 1980s, the book basis for the film, The Silent Brotherhood? The popularity of white supremacist groups at this time? The Reagan era? The social standing of members of the group, white groups, the biblical basis, church preachers, neo-Nazi attitudes, the active leaders and insurrection, turning to crime to finance militias?
3. The settings, Idaho, Washington state, the beauty of the mountain scenery? The city sequences, the streets, banks, porn cinema and explosions, homes, the church, the highways and robberies?
4. The focus Terry Husk, Jude Law’s performance, FBI background, moving to Idaho, the phone call and the separation from his wife and daughters, his long experience, long friendship with Joanne Carney, working with her, her authority and jurisdiction, tested by Husk and his taking initiatives? The work together, investigations?
5. The focus on the group, Richard Butler, as a church minister, his ideology, preaching, the Bible, white supremacist presuppositions about the land, anti-Semitic, swastikas and neo-Nazi attitudes? His meetings with Bob Matthews, the threats, Matthew standing up to him at the gathering, his withdrawing?
6. Bob Matthews, his background, age, manner, relationship with his wife, relationship with his girlfriend, her pregnancy? His friends, their thug background? Interviewing the Mexican who pretended he was Spanish for racial supremacy? His hold over the men, his leadership? Later, the arrest and Husk interviewing and getting information?
7. The decision to rob banks, the money, for themselves, but for funding a militias? The sequence of the robbing of the bank, intimidation, the driver and the getaway, his gun on the policeman outside, their exhilaration? Matthews and his wife and his girlfriend? The planting of the bomb in the cinema, a distraction, the robbery of the van? The bigger plans, the Brinks van, on the highway, the hold-up, cars on the highway, the chain across the road, their effectiveness, the dangers, guns and shooting, escape?
8. The local police, the chief, rather more easy-going, Jamie Bowen, his earnestness, relationship with his wife, children? Giving information to Husk? Husk relying on him, going to the motel, the stakeout, the gun, Jamie freezing, Husk and his reaction? His change, becoming more involved, going into action? Husk and the interview with his wife and her fear of him? The confrontation, the shootout, the chase, Jamie shot, his death? The funeral, Husk, Jamie’s wife?
9. The focus on Bob Matthews, his personality, relationships, his plans, his wife, unable to have children, the young girlfriend and the birth of the child, the money for them? Husk and his interview, getting information, the location for hide out?
10. The impact of the church gathering, Butler speaking, Matthews intervening, powerful speech, bigotry?
11. The hideout, the thugs, guard, the FBI attacked, the siege, the shooting? The fire, Bob Matthews staying, Husk going into the building, withdrawing, the collapse of the building, Matthews’ death?
12. Husk and his achievement, Joanne Carney and her work, the regrets for the death of Jamie Bowen? The atmosphere of uprisings in the 1980s?
13. The final information, the references to January 6th, the siege of the Capitol, The Proud Boys and other groups, imprisonment, President Trump pardoning them – and the future during the second Trump presidency?